Diaries
Everything
Who's Online?
FAQ
/
Help
WFC 8: Go vote
|
18
comments (18 topical, 0 hidden) |
Trackback
serious reviews
by
Kellnerin
(
4.00 / 3
)
#10
Wed Jan 30, 2008 at 06:54:09 AM EST
Hard-boiled crime originally sounded like a great idea for a WFC, but I think it's a lot more fun to read than it is to write. Maybe that's just me. Maybe 2500 words is not enough to hard-boil the crime. Still, not to diss the theme -- the fact that not everyone went the hard-boiled route made for more variety among the entries, which is always cool.
Wheel Man
Hunter would have made a mediocre journalist; the story has the Who, When, and Where but is missing a lot of What, How, and Why. I can't decide if it's a clever subversion of the crime genre or, er, the other thing.
Bird
Lack of details in the beginning (pronouns instead of people) made it hard for me to figure out who the protagonist and antagonist were at first. By the time I got a grip on the sitch I was expecting the ending to really seal it, but instead the twist lost me.
Dream Dagger
Was just getting interesting, then it ends. Great tone; a fine setup that's missing the actual story.
My Last Day Alive
I liked this one; even though it gives away its ending, the journey is satisfying. It's neatly executed (no pun intended -- wrong WFC), but not too neat.
Snake Eyes
Most hard-boiled, with all the classic elements except, perhaps, the crime. Has some fun turns of phrase, a logical gap or two, and an odd obsession with furniture.
Country Manners
This was the only story that gave me a real, visceral shock. (I realize most of the other stories were not going for that effect.) Not hard-boiled, but its atmosphere is thick with crime and the story has its own, distinct voice.
Props to everyone brave enough to submit something. Thanks, as always, to 2 plus 3 equals 5 for coordinating, and to notafurry for the technical enablement.
--
"Late to the party" is the new "ahead of the curve"
-- CRwM
WFC 8: Go vote
|
18
comments (18 topical, 0 hidden) |
Trackback
Login
Make a new account
Username:
Password: